Club 23 Comments

2.8

29-23 23rd Ave

Astoria, New York 11105

55,554 Views228 Comments  

Cynthia G.  on Club 23

posted on 23 November, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Truly a wonderful experience! Just celebrated my son's High School graduation. The service was on point - very family oriented. We were treated as if we were family. We asked for the items that were not on the menu and they prepared them with no objection. The appetizers (burrata, calamari fritte, salumi) all delicious. The entrees were scrumptious and the Tartuffo on brioche to die for. This is my new favorite place. We met the owner who was down to earth. He surprised us with a bottle of champagne to celebrate my son's graduation - I was truly touched! Shout out to Pino - u were great. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience. We Jersey folks will be back! Please take a chance and visit Ornella - you will not regret it. Everyone is nice and they aim to please!

Mary W.  on Club 23

posted on 14 November, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Delicious small family run restaurant. Most pasta dishes are homemade. Great menu choices.Nice cozy atmosphere great service. I will return to this place soon.

nick o.  on Club 23

posted on 26 October, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Food is great but the host overcharged me. They still lied after I called them out on it .Make sure you are clear on the price when you order.

Franklyn  on  Club 23

posted on 27 September, 2016
Joined 7 years ago
141 comments posted

Ornella is da bomb. If you have a gluten sensitivity and are depressed by a lack of options for Italian, Ornella will lift you out of the darkness and into sunshine and blue skies. If you don't have a sensitivity, still have their chestnut, buckwheat, or chickpea flour pasta. Their in house made pasta options are exquisite--- the Gnocchi is divine; pasta di Castagna supremely decadent. If you want an authentic Italian experience, you must go to Ornella-- truly a culinary celebration. And that is not hyperbole.

livinlikelarry  on  Club 23

posted on 27 September, 2016

10 comments posted

The best Italian restaurant in Astoria! Consistently delicious food and a great atmosphere!

Mike D.  on Club 23

posted on 22 September, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Cute place. Pino, owners son was great. Food was solid around, esp stuffed pork chop.

danielson  on  Club 23

posted on 15 September, 2016
Joined 2 years ago
33 comments posted

The best italian restaurant so far .sergio was the friendliest server and very warm .i ordered the castgna pasta and my friend ordered the pork chop .sergio ever offered us to try the pesto pasta himself made .top notch service .will be back with my friends and family to enjoy the excellent food and service here :)

dopeboy19  on  Club 23

posted on 8 September, 2016
Joined 2 years ago
45 comments posted

I have been here two times and I enjoyed both experiences. Pino and his brother (chef) were really nice. We started off with the baked clams and mozzarella, both were delicious. For the main course we ordered the short ribs and amatriciana, both very good. Pino, our waiter was very personable and provided excellent service. His brother even came out of the kitchen to say hello. I love the fact that the whole family works here, makes me feel at home. The second time we came I had the carbonara, it was good but I honestly believe it could have been less wet. To me it needed a little more grated cheese, but that is just me. It was still good. My girlfriend got the bolognese which was very good. The homemade prosciutto was delicious. Keep up the good work guys. P.S. I love your responses to the negative reviews.

Maria D.  on Club 23

posted on 3 September, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

As a follow up to a previous review, the owner should be more concerned with his filthy bathroom, dirty silverware and drinking glasses and non-attentive wait staff, and pay less attention to how customers dress. I could only imagine how unsanitary the kitchen is. For an Italian restaurant, the tomato sauce was bland & watered down and the bolognese sauce was flavorless, which is an absolute disgrace. I did not want "soup" as the owner implied, I just enjoy my pasta with extra sauce. As it was the portion size was too small and overpriced and lacked flavor and the proper amount of sauce to begin with. It is clear the owner knows nothing about running a successful Italian restaurant. His skills, arrogance and classless attitude barely qualify him to be a dishwasher let alone a restaurant owner. For those who are looking to experience an enjoyable, memorable and flavorful Italian dinner, I suggest dining around the corner at Trattoria L'Incontro.

Vanessa C.  on Club 23

posted on 1 September, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Such a cute place! The food is fantastic as well as the owner! My friends and I love this place! We go come here for dinner once a month and it's always amazing!

maxxy1  on  Club 23

posted on 23 August, 2016
Joined 8 years ago
159 comments posted

My boyfriend and I have been wanting to try this restaurant for a while. He is Italian and we don't usually go out for Italian food as we still get to enjoy his family's homemade food quite often. Tonight we finally tried Ornella Trattoria, and we were very happy. The bread brought to our table reminded my boyfriend of the bread his Nonna served during his childhood. We split a pear/walnut/Gorgonzola salad, and my boyfriend ordered the veal, which was very tender. I was trying to decide between the swordfish and a gluten free (chickpea) pasta. I asked the server, and he recommended the pasta. I have to say, I admire a restaurant that doesn't try too hard to "upsell" by pushing the more expensive dish. I was happy I ordered the pasta, which the server told me I could get with any sauce (I chose pesto). We also shared a bottle of red wine, and I was happy that they had one of my favorite wines from California (where I grew up). We left in good standing with the "clean plate club," as we enjoyed every bite of the meal.We will definitely return, as we have not yet tried the meatballs.

navid  on  Club 23

posted on 18 August, 2016
Joined 1 year ago
19 comments posted

Small mom and pop restaurant with great food. Had the duck meatballs and lobster ravioli. Both were delicious. The staff was friendly and courteous. Will definitely be going back soon!

Madia L.  on Club 23

posted on 13 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

One of my favorite Italian restaurants in NYC! I often travel to Italy so my standards are quite high when it comes to Italian dishes. The dishes at Ornella went above and beyond. The ambiance, cuisine and hospitality was perfect. The owner was very welcoming and kind from beginning to end. Definitely come to Ornella if you're in the area!

Romina W.  on Club 23

posted on 7 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I ordered delivery from Ornella last night and it was not a good experience. I ordered 2 pasta dishes and asked for extra cheese and sauce on the side (I actually paid extra for the cheese too). When my order arrived it was bare bones. No cheese or sauce on side, no utensils, not even bread. When I called the restaurant to let them know my order was missing items, they said that I had ordered a pasta dish which is a carb so they don't give you bread with carb orders. This makes no sense. They also said they put cheese on the pasta dish, but there was none.The spagetti and meatballs were mushy and over cooked. The linguni with pesto sauce was delicious. I've eaten at the restaurant before and it was a great experience. They just need to improve their customer service for delivery as I will never order from them again.

Jen R.  on Club 23

posted on 6 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Can't wait for my leftovers. With so many options in Astoria, my husband and I have always been disappointed with some of the Italian choices until we took a chance and came here.Service: Great! Waiters and the owner Giuseppe were very attentive. My meal came with spaghetti and they easy changed it for cavatelli Food: delicious! Not disappointed at all. Appetizer - Cesar salad and Italian meat & mozzarella cheese platter with sweet onions and raspberry marmalade, which was a special. The meat was cured in Giuseppe's house upstate and it was fresh and delicious. The salad was fine as well, but that platter though!!! Main Course: Stuffed porkchop with mushroom and substitute cavatelli was amazing. Plenty of fontina cheese and overall delicious. The cavatelli was al dente, which I particularly don't love, but still good and will just ask them to cook it a little longer next time we go. Lobster Ravioli - really good!! No room for dessert and complimentary lemonchello.

Angela L.  on Club 23

posted on 5 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I've been to many restaurants in Astoria but Ornella Trattoria Italiana is by far the best one out of them all. Located minutes away from Astoria park Ornella's is a true gem. Dinning in is a wonderful experience. You're greeted and served by friendly and knowledgeable staff who cater to all your needs. My mother came in from out of town on a Friday night and she was a little skeptical when taking her first look at the menu. There are many unique and diverse dishes so I asked the waiter for his recommendations. We tried the duck meatballs and the people behind us insisted we also try the homemade prosciutto and cheeses with homemade jams as an appetizer. It turned out to be an excellent choice. Then it was on to the main course. I went with the freshly made chestnut pasta and my mother had the freshly made hemp pasta. I was absolutely blown away. Never have I had or heard of either of these dishes before. After an amazing dinner we had the pleasure of meeting the owner himself. It seems as if he takes much pride in all of his dishes and his entire operation. We didn't have room for dessert but he gave us a complimentary Limoncello.

James D.  on Club 23

posted on 28 July, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Came here on a Thursday night for their $10 pasta special and had the Carbonara, it was very good, also had a bit of the lasagna which nice. Would definitely come here again.

Ginna A.  on Club 23

posted on 19 July, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I came to Ornella with my boyfriend last week and I cant describe with words how good it was. The owner and waiters were all so kind, we used the groupon, and had such a good time, we will be back, the atmosphere and food are so so good.

Clayton H.  on Club 23

posted on 8 June, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I've been going to Ornella about once a week for a couple of months now. I am the grandson of Italian immigrants, "going out" for Italian isn't something I do often, and of course I'm very picky.Giuseppe: I love your place, truly I do. Most Italian restaurants cater to customers looking for red sauce and polpette. But you serve the food that Italians eat in their homes. You and your staff are always very enjoyable hosts. Your food reminds me of what I would eat at my own Nonnas table. I also greatly admire the manner in which you stand up for yourself against negative reviewers. You have earned a customer for life in me Mr. Vitale. Keep up the fantastic work! One request for my most favorite dish in the world. Not often found on menus: How can I convince you to place Osso Bucco on the menu?

Mah B.  on Club 23

posted on 19 May, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

after walking past this small old school establishment numerous times... we finally made it in there..... I'm keeping it short..... the closest your getting to Authentic Italian food is by buying a ticket to Italy....... food is deeeelish.. take from a person with deep italian roots... it's a must visit

Dearbhail K.  on Club 23

posted on 16 May, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Have nothing only great things to say about this place. The food, the atmosphere and the staff where exemplary. Both me and my boyfriend had a good laugh at the bathroom decor...very nice touch. We will be back again very soon, keeping business alive in the Astoria neighborhood is key!

theresa m.  on Club 23

posted on 14 May, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I Looking forward to an evening of good food & wine to celebrate a dear friends birthday got off to a very bad start.I called Ornella for a reservation, very late on Saturday evening asking if they could accommodate us in short notice. They said it would be 30 minutes, but we could sit at the bar. Great, I thought, this will work.Arriving at the restaurant, I see that there are about empty tables, but they could not sit more than one party at a time. Odd, but OK. The bar does not exist. A counter with two stools & an old newspaper on it. OK, we were not looking for a bar.We hare seated at a table for four, but only three chairs. It is not set. They bring a bottle of water and only one glass. We order a bottle of wine with some appetizers. The beef carpaccio was far too thick & no seasoning, the baked clams were OK, not wonderful & the calamari bland. As were reviewing the entrees, we ordered a 2nd bottle of wine. They were out. How is a restaurant out of Malbec on a Saturday night of Mother's Day weekend? We were told, to just order the house wine, as that is all they had. When I ask the owner how he could not have any more wine or why we were not told there was only one bottle left, so we could have chosen another, he reply is makes me speechless. He stood there in a loud rude voice " Did you come here to eat, or complain?" When he saw the look on our faces, he claimed he was joking. I stated "No, you are not". At which point, the birthday lady stood up to leave, as she ask he to repeat what he said. HE turned white, and stated that everything was on him & walked away. It is the first time I have ever been treated so rudely. Did he really think we had not right to question him? Does he really think that is food is so fab that anyone would put up with him & his nasty chef son who had the nerve to then question me as I stupidly tried to tip our waiter? I was told not to go, but did not listen. I will not ignore my friends suggestions again.I am sure this will be placed in the ladies room where he proudly post negative reviews. We should have left then. The good thing? We ended up at Trattoria L'incontro for a wonder meal & amazing service. Maybe the folks at Ornella can take lessons.********* I have posted on FACEBOOK & we did go to L'Incontro, I am happy to post the bill.I did call and showed up in 10 minutes, agreed. I have no idea what you are talking about another place. I had booked a table on-line & cancelled due a friend telling me bad you are. I should have listen.Bottom line. You are rude. They fact that you say "Ladies" they way you do show this. I even tipped the waiter,because at least he knows he job. And yes, the birthday girl did say that while laughing, and yes I will tell you that only having a few bottles of wine is odd and you are very rude. I cannot say that enough!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ed C.  on Club 23

posted on 5 May, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I love this place....the food is awesome and it's very comfortable place to meet friends or have a romantic date. Everything is very flavorful and great portions...the owner is really cool and smart and takes great pride in his craft of an impeccable customer experience. His son has a similar vibe and personality. I like when there is a two generation restaurant.

moneyman2  on  Club 23

posted on 4 May, 2016
Joined 2 years ago
28 comments posted

Excellent authentic Italian. The chestnut pasta was to die for. Service and atmosphere was also great.

anthony1  on  Club 23

posted on 24 April, 2016
Joined 2 years ago
23 comments posted

Love Ornella! Can't beat the friendly, family vibe inside. No need to go into Manhattan for a delicious Italian feast. The pasta dishes at Ornella are some of the best I've had in NYC! Try the pesto (so fresh and delicious). The gnocchi is also a very good dish for cheese-lovers. The penne with tomato sauce is basic but such comfort food. Fave Italian in the neighborhood!

E V.  on Club 23

posted on 13 April, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Writing this before I fall into a food coma! After reading the reviews, especially the bad ones, I knew I had to order from here. The owner doesn't hold back when responding to the negative reviews which made me want to try this place out. Anyone that can respond like that must know they have damn good food.The food was amazing and worth the wait which was estimated to be about an hour and showed up a little early. I will be ordering from here again!!!

marlonmoney12  on  Club 23

posted on 2 April, 2016
Joined 2 years ago
31 comments posted

I came here on a late Thursday afternoon with my two friends for dinner. Thursday happens to be $10 pasta night, which is such a great deal. They only have the basic pasta dishes on the $10 menu, so don't expect your chestnut pasta to be on it LOL. When we came here, there were no other customers in the restaurants so we were given all the attention. The waiter was so attentive to our needs and kept asking us if we are satisfied and comfortable and if we needed anything else. The owner also came out and said hello to us, which I really appreciate because I don't see a lot of restaurant owners interacting with their customers often. Anyway, it was my first time at this place and I came all the way from flushing because my friends and I heard that the food here is really good (plus you can't beat $10 pasta). After reading all the reviews, I was itching to try the chestnut pasta! It also sounded pretty peculiar and so out of the box that I had to get it, even if the other $10 pastas were calling my name at the same time...I opted for what I thought would satisfy my taste buds best. When the plate arrived on my table, I was not disappointed with the QUANTITY, the dish was around $17 so I better get the amount of food that I paid for right? When I took my first bite, I told myself "Wow this is really unique and delicious" but unfortunately for me, after a few more bites, I just couldn't bear to swallow another bite. It just got overwhelmingly sweet for me and I guess I wasn't expecting that; I've been so used to savory pasta and not sweet pasta. I could't finish my plate at all and I gave it to my friend who found it delicious and agreeable to her palate. So in the end, I believe it is a matter of acquired taste, I wish I had ordered something different, I was just soo caught up in the hype of the infamous chestnut pasta. I might come back in the future, but I definitely would need to order something else.

Burton M.  on Club 23

posted on 26 March, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

We have dined here on perhaps ten occasions. The food is consistently great, with special consideration being called out to the white salad (artichoke and mushroom based), fish specials, pasta "with the milk", burrata, steak pizzaola, and above all else the chestnut pasta. There are many other made-in-house pastas.

Ethan R.  on Club 23

posted on 12 March, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Loved the Pasta di Castagne! It is an absolute must try if you are looking for a unique Italian dish. It's pasta made with chestnut flour in a white cream pistachio sauce. The service is good and the environment is laid back and comfortable. I will definitely be back when I'm in this part of Astoria.

Jordan C.  on Club 23

posted on 13 January, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I made reservations for my family on Christmas night. Props to this cute and classy little joint for being open (and crazy busy). The painted walls and indoor environment evoked stories of the 2 weeks that my mother spent in Italy about a month ago - she felt like it reminded her of the little cafe's that lined many of the streets throughout her travels. I'm not sure that's quite the ringing endorsement I mean it to be, but just know that middle-aged jewish women may find the ambiance to be very authentic.The food is FANTASTIC. Everything is presented in a very appetizing manner, and the smells really draw you into each dish. The portions are beyond healthy (no one at my table was able to finish their whole entree). I had one of the evening's specials - a pappardalle with short rib ragu. And wow. Just wow.To me, it's wonderful when a place isn't a caricature of it's origins - like any pizza joint that serves eggplant parm and shows up on a list as being Italian food (not that there is anything wrong with that at all, I LOVE pizza) - and Ornella's eclectic menu, full of more than just the standard "Italian" fare, hits all the rights notes for me. However, some of my party are more picky eaters who were less impressed with the range of dishes on the menu. Problem, right? Wrong! When my aunt started to fret that everything was a little too "different" for her taste, we came across a little note on the menu - if you're looking for something more standard, just ask for chicken parm, or any of the staples, and they'll be more than happy to accommodate.Our servers were prompt and friendly, and clearly working hard with a packed house on their holiday evening. Cheers to them!The only hiccup on the evening was the timing of our reservation. We arrived a few minutes early for our 6:30pm and we were acknowledged, but then stood around for about 40 or 45 minutes before we were seated. While it was nice that the owner wasn't blowing smoke about how it would only be another few minutes, just another few minutes only to be kept waiting, it was a little aggravating that he suggested we order while we were standing around, crowded in by the door. I appreciate that it was a very busy night, and Christmas to boot, but even a tiny apology for the wait would have been nice - certainly more warm and fuzzy than "hey, maybe if you order now, you won't have to wait when you sit". Like everyone else who had a table, we wanted to sit and wait - it's why we made reservations at your restaurant!Not that this will stop me from coming back. Even if I was that angry, the food means that I have to come back - there is too much more deliciousness left on the menu to try!

Kelly S.  on Club 23

posted on 10 December, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Great Italian gem in Astoria. My mother, daughter & I arrived around 7:00, and were seated immediately. Personalized attention by all (father and sons? We didnt get all the details). We ordered a carafe of wine, bruschetta & a caesar salad to share. Bruschetta was different, sausage instead of chopped tomatoes, but delish. Caesar salad was fresh and the best i have had in a while. We ordered cavatelli with vodka sauce and chicken parm for 3 of us to share. Again, fresh, home-made and delicious. Topped it off with chocolate mousse cake and tiramissu. We were treated to after-dinner moscadella (?) - not my favorite, but a nice gesture. Overall, good for my family, young families, couples, and romantic dinners. Very accommodating staff. We will return!

Regina H.  on Club 23

posted on 3 December, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

This place is fantastic! The food was excellent and the owner was so kind and advised us to order exactly as the menu had the pasta described. He was right- it was fabulous. We had a nice conversation with him on the way out and the service was fabulous. Great prices, too! Will definitely be back to this place, it's got a great atmosphere.

Dan L.  on Club 23

posted on 21 November, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

That chestnut pasta, though...I've been to Ornella time after time, and each time it is more delicious than the last. The feel is authentic, the food is homemade and truly Italian, and the staff is friendly. We've had the chestnut pasta, the cannelloni, the chicken parm, several fish dishes, fried calamari and more. It is all delicious. Yu seriously can't go wrong.You'll know you're in the right place, and on the right path, when you see the handwritten menu, written in fancy cursive letters. The experience at Ornella is a delight, and makes me feel like I've moved from Queens straight out to a small town in Italy.Seriously, try the chestnut pasta. It sounds bizarre, but is one of the tastier Italian dishes I've ever had.

Eric H.  on Club 23

posted on 20 November, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Anyone who's met Giuseppe can tell he's got a real passion for food. The pasta dishes are unique here, and don't hamper the taste for the sake of being unique. I've hosted a meetup here and Giuseppe is very accomodating.My favorite dishes here are the stuffed pork chop and the home made gnocchi. The hemp pasta is also a must try, you'd be hard pressed to find something similar elsewhere.

james1412  on  Club 23

posted on 6 November, 2015
Joined 4 years ago
103 comments posted

We ate here last night and it was fantastic. The owner Giuseppe sat us and took our order personally. He answered questions, was courteous and gave us a good vibe from the go.After we ordered he asked if we wanted a drink with dinner...upon saying sure...do you have a house wine...he came over with a carafe brimming to the edge. The wine was great and came right as the starters arrived. We went with the duck meatballs and let me tell you...they were two of the best meatballs we've ever tasted. I'm Italian, family from overseas, and lived in Little Italy...I know good meatballs and these were spot on! They're obviously made with duck...have a spot of cheese in the center and have a glaze that is unreal...decadent...Definitely try them!Next up was the prosciutto and pear appetizer...this too was excellent.Our entrees came out after a short time...I had the short ribs and my wife had imbustata...both were absolutely awesome. Cooked perfectly, short rib falling off the bone with home made fresh gnocci. The imbustata also tasted great and the pasta envelope was cooked perfectly. We finished everything and during the meal Giuseppe checked in on us...even saying..if there's something you don't like...I'll bring it back and let you try something else. Now that's great to hear...you rarely have a restaurant owner going to lengths like that to make sure your dining experience is great!We ordered dessert tiramisu and the Italian cheesecake with a latte and a cappuccino. Before it even arrived Giuseppe came over with two cordial glasses filled with sambucca, saying these are to help with digestion and are on the house. It made for a great ending to an absolutely kick ass meal. We highly recommend and plan on going back again soon. BTW the place is quaint, clean, nicely decorated, and the murals are great. You can see that he takes pride in the place and that's great. Too many of these small restaurants simply open up for the "hipster money" that's all over Astoria nowadays and care little for the "experience" of the entire meal. Everyone thinks they're a trained food critic instead of actually communicating with the server/owner/chefs...Sit back, put your phone down, and enjoy the meal.Thanks for reading.

Sheva E.  on Club 23

posted on 29 October, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

I'm genuinely surprised by some of these reviews, this was probably the worst restaurant I have ever been to. It makes me rethink any bad review I have ever given because it was so terrible. The products they use taste like they come from a can and nothing tasted fresh. Some of the appetizers ordered were covered in cream and cheese to mask fresh supposedly veggies and the proteins in the entrees tasted like they were thawed from the freezer and old. If you are looking for good Italian there are so many other places to go please do not waste your money here.The only good thing about this place was the kindness from the owner. He had a nice attitude and he is extremely friendly.

Junie A.  on Club 23

posted on 29 October, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Delicious dishes made from scratch and priced affordably. Steak night is my favorite!!!

Veronica K.  on Club 23

posted on 12 October, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Had dinner for the first time there tonight. Food was delicious and plentiful!! Service was excellent. Owner was very welcoming!! Would highly recommend!!

Johnson12  on  Club 23

posted on 21 September, 2015
Joined 3 years ago
92 comments posted

I went here for living social deal. It was a great deal and I always wanted to try this place. I loved the vibe: very Italian rustic. The food was fantastic: let me clarify.. Pasta was good. I had stuffed pork and i honestly did not like the pork. It just wasn't my cup of tea. The meat was chewy and there was a spinach like stuffing that just wasn't my Cup of tea. However the pasta on the side was so delicious. My date had short ribs.. It was a lot better than pork! And the gnocchi was seriously so good. We had duck meatballs: i loved the meatball but it was smothered in sweet sauce . I would ask he sauce on the side rather than on the plate. Would I go back? Yes. I would go back and get pasta. And try the duck meatballs with sauce on the side. The portions are huge!!

Edward W.  on Club 23

posted on 5 September, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

What a place. The food was excellent. I went with a party of 3 and we were all deciding what to get and we were all intrigued by the chestnut pasta but none of us ended up ordering it. The owner was so gracious that he brought us an order to share on the house. Now that is service.The menu is extensive and the feel of the restaurant is just good. I would definitely recommend it and will surely be back!

Nate R.  on Club 23

posted on 13 August, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

My Girlfriend and I went here with high hopes of a new tasty Italian spot. We couldn't of been happier. Excellent service and the owner took the time to buy us a drink and chat a bit. The food was amazing as well. We both had a great experience overall and will definitely stop in again.

Melinda K.  on Club 23

posted on 11 July, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Amazing food the best Italian dinner since I was in Italy. The pasta has the perfect bite. Every dish Is perfect it's just what you are in the mood for. I will return for the food the service and the funny stories the owner tells so well.Thank you.Melinda

Nicole K.  on Club 23

posted on 7 July, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

I was craving a classic Italian dish with all the must have's: tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, warm bread, delectable wine, and have came across my dream come true. Right when you walk in, you are greeted by a warm staff in a welcoming, classic and fitting environment. The menu is vast and it is very easy to find something for everyone. Chicken Parmesan was nothing short of perfection, and the service was quick. There is a cute small bar and the atmosphere reminded me of a mix between my Italian Nonna's cooking mixed with Little Italy. Yum, I will be back.

A L.  on Club 23

posted on 25 June, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Placed was recommended by a friend. Such a nice little gem on a busy street. I believe it was the owner who was very attentive and always checked in on us. Calamari was excellent and the broccoli rabe!

Katrina B.  on Club 23

posted on 23 June, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

a great italian place in a nice part of astoria!the staff was extremely friendly and attentive. the bread was okay to start off with. it seemed a little old but not offensively old. we ordered a bunch of food and everything came out with good timing. we got two of the delizia salads, two imbustatas, and one order of the fried calamari, linguine di mare and the pasta di castagna. everything was delicious! especially the castagna. highly recommend it but beware that its very heavy!the imbustata was tasty too but again, really heavy. i love that they serve fresh pasta. i love homemade pasta. the salads had a great balsamic reduction. the calamari was light and crispy. and the linguine di mare was great too!pricing was a bit high but you can tell that the people who work there really love the restaurant and its reflective in their food.

Randi S.  on Club 23

posted on 15 June, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Met some locals here for dinner at their recommendation, and I'm glad we went. It's a small hole-in-the-wall place which has just been renovated. According to our friends, it made the restaurant less homey and more run-of-the-mill. It's a little cramped, but you can expect that in this neighbourhood. Service was good, if a little slow. We ended up missing out on the end of meal limoncello because they weren't sure if we were drinkers. Would have been nice, but wasn't a deal breaker. The table split the duck meatballs, which were good, but not amazing. The rest of the table enjoyed them, but I probably wouldn't order them again. They were a little dry and served in an interesting raisin chutney sauce. The table also shared Pasta di Castagna, which was delicious but very rich. I would not recommend it as an entree, since it is very rich and a little heavy, but do try it. The chestnut pasta is unique and delicious. My entree was the Pasta Carbonara, which surprisingly had very large chunks of pancetta - no complaints here though! The sauce was thick without being gelatinous, and coated everything very well. Taste-wise, it was great and I would recommend it. My husband had the Pork Chop Milanese, which was good, though a little tough to cut. All in all, a good place. Maybe won't blow you away, but it's a reasonably priced Italian joint that would be a stand by for us if we were local.

Amanda H.  on Club 23

posted on 4 June, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

I really wanted to like this place. The owner is a gem and the staff are all very pleasant. The food is just incredibly baffling. We dined here twice; the first time was very unimpressive and but we decided to give it another shot - hey, maybe the place was having a bad night? Second time around, I ordered the stuffed filet of sole and my SO ordered a pasta special; meatballs and gnocchi-like pasta. The flavors in the pasta special were severely lacking and my filet of sole was incredibly fishy and salty. Unsurprisingly, we both got food poisoning and spent the next 12 hours expunging our systems of this meal. We ordered different entrees both visits and both times were really quite terrible.I am a very big fan of the growing Astoria dining scene and I just cannot bring myself to try this place a third time.

ryan123  on  Club 23

posted on 7 May, 2015
Joined 9 years ago
181 comments posted

Finally made it to this hidden gem...The owner is on hand and does it all !! I went with a party of four and all seemed happy with their dishes, the pasta is fresh and the apps were wonderful !! I highly recommend this place....

yanard12  on  Club 23

posted on 20 April, 2015
Joined 3 years ago
89 comments posted

This place is a great find in Astoria, and I'm surprised that I didn't find out how good it is sooner. I think it's just a bit unassuming from the outside. But after having it recommended to me, I went to dinner with my girlfriend, and we had a delicious three course meal for a decent price. I'll definitely be back, and I highly recommend it if you're looking for a really solid Italian restaurant in the area.

Blake S.  on Club 23

posted on 9 April, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

This little amazing restaurant has great food and wonderful service. Pasta Carbonara is delicious!!!

Jam L.  on Club 23

posted on 10 March, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

A quaint Italian restaurant, unpretentious and simple. The food is good, flavorful. We had the cap rear and grilled calamari and for entre the carbonara and seafood pasta. We'll come back for more

Brian H.  on Club 23

posted on 9 March, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Family style Italian. Their pasta dishes are excellent, and we would recommend the duck meatballs and Aspari di Campo on their appatiser menu. We've dined there as well as gotten delivery. It's certainly worth eating at the restaurent- they are generous with the wine (the house red is good), and I really like the plating versus a delivery box. Must try for Astoria.

igor34  on  Club 23

posted on 27 February, 2015
Joined 4 years ago
108 comments posted

Went to this restaurant a couple of weeks ago and I still remember it. The food was surprisingly very good, while I got the Fettuccine Alfredo, that was out of this world. The mood, from the start, was great with a nice environment and nice people. Although the staff could have helped me a little more, they overall were very friendly and delightful to talk too. This restaurant wasn't over the top, reason for the rate, but if your looking for a nice evening, with good food and hospitality, then this is the place.

Imellynn E.  on Club 23

posted on 17 February, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

We came here for our Valentine's dinner, the owner was very personable and accommodating, I originally wanted the short ribs but they ran out, so he offered the stuffed porkchop with gnocchi instead, which was a big serving of an impressive culinary art, which really made my night. The Burrata and salmon appetizer took my breath away, it was a great fusion of flavors that really wakes your palette. The ambience had a feel of being welcomed by an amazing family's home. We highly recommend this to friends and family, and will definitely be coming back, for celebrations, special occasions, date nights, and just for getting together.

billtheguy12  on  Club 23

posted on 6 February, 2015
Joined 3 years ago
80 comments posted

I had a pretty bad experience with this place I ordered on grub hub and I was expecting to receive what I ordered but unfortunately I was really disappointed with the stuff I got. I ordered grilled skirt steak cooked medium rare, and Italian cheesecake and received New York cheesecake very bad quality and the steak was not a skirt steak, it was 4 pieces of meat, I'm not sure if it was like leftovers from a different cut of meat but definitely not skirt steak, also it was way overcooked. It's false advertising when you pretend to sell something you do not have, at least call the customer and let them know what you will send. In the end someone from the restaurant gave me a call and told me this is how they do the steak and they didn't have the Italian cheese cake so I got what I got, also they send someone to pick up the food back, very unprofessional staff.

Nova C.  on Club 23

posted on 6 January, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Happy New Years everyone. I never write reviews but I have never felt so disrespected in a restaurant the way I did in this place. I thought things like this only occurred in movies. Yesterday, for New Year's Eve, some old friends of mine and I were in the mood for Italian food. We decided to come here since my coworker recommended it a long time ago. We called fifteen minutes before arriving and they were polite, saying they were clearing up a table for us. While standing, the owner gave us the menus and we all knew what we were going to order. Standing for a while next to the espresso bar, we watched the owner make two cups of cappuccino. It smelled heavenly! We asked what the price was for it since there were no prices listed for drinks or wine on the menu. He said, "it's cheaper than Starbucks" & we all laughed. But he had such a weird look on his face...he told us repetitively that if we were on a budget there's a nice place next door cheaper than his restaurant. I was shocked. His entrees were around $22-$30 at max which is the average price of any authentic Indian cuisine (we are from Bangladesh). I said we weren't on a budget however I couldn't stand there another minute. We politely left but I would do anything to go back and ask him how could an owner say such a thing? How does he make his judgements? I am a medical assistant, my boyfriend is doing well with his business, my friends have great jobs. Did we look like poor twenty year olds? Is it because we are Indian? Tell me. And if asking how much your drinks are is wrong, then next time give us drink menus. But please check out this restaurant, if it is worth it. Don't let an ignorant owner stop you!

Abby W.  on Club 23

posted on 6 January, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

They've gone downhill significantly in the past couple of years and I've given up. Steak ordered rare comes out tasteless and well done. Pasta arrives overcooked and congealed. Bread is stale. I even tried delivery and the duck meatball was a solid, sugary mass of inedible orange. It's sad because they really try with the various nightly specials and cordial service but with so many other neighborhood choices, it's just not worth it.

Jack D.  on Club 23

posted on 30 December, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Astoria is home to many types of places: greek cuisine, hookah on Steinway , and places like " the Thirsty Koala". There are also little Italian gems spread around the neighborhood. I was able to dine at one of these establishments on a random Sunday night, few days shy of thw upcoming new year of 2015. Ornella traitorra is a very welcoming place and has a family vibe to it. Most likely a family owned and operated restaurant. I was recommended to come here by a client of mine at work and this place did not disappoint. Thw restaurant is more lengthy , than wide (think of a long hallway) with tables and chairs near to each other but not in the way. It was a calm, quiet Sunday night with a few patrons dining. We were immediately sat and presented with a menu. With the growling of our stomachs , we had ordered our food quickly. We started of with a twist on a calamari dish. It was grilled calamari , not fried, in an interesting, zesty sauce placed on a bed of arugula , sprinkled around with slices of orange. This was accompanied with the "Delizia" salad, which is most like italian for delicious, which it was . The apps went well with 2 nicely chilled glasses of semi- sweet Cabernet Savignon. The entrees were the penne ala vodka for the spouse and I had the shell steak , medium rare with potaotes and veggies. Food was spectacular , better than either of us thought it would. Totally worth it. Great spot. Check it out if you are in the area.

Soren N.  on Club 23

posted on 21 December, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Ate here for their $10 Thursday Pasta night and it was really delicious. The lasagna was really well made and had a great fresh Caesar salad. The stuff was attentive and had a really nice evening. The linguine el pesto was nice and creamy. I really recommend this place for dining in or date night.

Brian C.  on Club 23

posted on 17 December, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I dined at Ornella Trattoria Italiana on a slow weekday afternoon (we were the only people dining in the restaurant), which was surprising even to me as I generally avoid empty restaurants. I was taking my grandparents out to lunch, so we decided to stay and not go through the hassle of looking for a new place. The restaurant itself was clean and spacious, and offered a variety of vegetarian options. We had friendly service, though the food completely missed the mark. I ordered the pappardelle ragu, and something about it was just completely off. The meat and sauce were completely bland, and the pasta had a really weird texture to it, almost as if it was coated in raw flour or something. I tried to add salt to save the dish, but it wasn't working for me and I left over half of my dish behind. My grandpa had the mushroom risotto, which came out hard and undercooked, even though I requested for it to be overcooked. I ended up sending the dish back over two times to have it cooked more so that the risotto would be softer, but it came back as hard as raw rice each time. The risotto didn't have a smooth and creamy texture, but instead was more like flavorless globs of raw rice. This was by far my largest disappointment as I hated seeing my grandpa try to eat something that obviously wasn't good. We tried to season it more, too, but he ended up eating less than half of the dish before giving up on it. My grandma had the stuffed pork chop, which I didn't get to try for myself. It looked well cooked and she said it was good, so I'm glad someone enjoyed their dish!Ang had the chestnut pasta, which had an unusual texture due to the fact that it was made of chestnuts, but the dish wasn't bad with some salt added. I wouldn't say it was anything special, but it was better than what my grandpa and I had. Again, the service was good. We literally were the only people dining in the restaurant and didn't see any orders going out for delivery, so the manager was able to give us extra attention. We had casual small talk, and were treated to try the cheesecake and tiramisu. They were both good, but nothing at the restaurant was pushing "great."

Demo K.  on Club 23

posted on 1 December, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Service was slow. Found Myself constantly asking for things. Water, bread, butter, balsamic. Staff was friendly but this place got overwhelmed quickly.

Amanda A.  on Club 23

posted on 15 November, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Bad service they serve from guest food to ur table omg never come back sorry to the owner he is nice but the employee no good :(

Fadda M.  on Club 23

posted on 7 November, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Came with my daughter on a rainy night last week, and had a beautiful experience. It was crowded, considering that it was a rainy week-night, and all of the customers seemed happy, and were enjoying themselves and the food, which was delicious, and obviously carefully prepared.I find the angry, bitter reviews on here strange, as neither my party or anyone else in the restaurant seemed to be having anything other than a great time.The service was attentive, warm, and friendly, and the wine pour was generous, with a romantic vibe in the place.I came all the way from Brooklyn to dine here, and am looking forward to returning soon. And YES, we used a Groupon !

Cassey P.  on Club 23

posted on 18 October, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Just delicious. Have been there for dinner once or twice, will definitely come back again! Love their pasta specials

Yury U.  on Club 23

posted on 12 October, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

XhXeXy  on  Club 23

posted on 10 October, 2014
Joined 8 years ago
146 comments posted

Maybe I came on an off weekday, but being an Italian from The Bronx, I didn't like this place at all.I ordered the stuffed pork chop and it was terrible. The sauce was watery and odd. The pork chop was hot on the inside, cold on the outside, and tough...

Sadaf S.  on Club 23

posted on 5 September, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Ornella seems like a traditional authentic restaurant that that has been around for years. Overall, the food took a while, but was worth the wait. We had the gnocchi, whole wheat penne and the risotto which was delicious. The servers were friendly as well. We wanted to order a pizza but the oven wasn't working so we weren't able to try it. But maybe next time!

Grace A.  on Club 23

posted on 29 July, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I had to give 5 stars to this restaurant, I rang other Italians in the area to try and find lasagne and this was the only one that had it so they had a head start! All I wanted was a nice lasagne and my craving has been thoroughly satisfied now after demolishing their delicious lasagne in no time at all! I called the order in for pick up and while I waited (not long at all) I chatted to the owner and server, who were both lovely. Thank you, I will be back!

Jessica N.  on Club 23

posted on 16 July, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Bought a groupon for $25 for $50 worth of good and I am glad we did! The place is very small, I wouldn't recommend brining the kiddies it's so tight. My toddler was going absolutely crazy so I had to take her outside for a few walks (the high chair straps were broken, biggest pet peeve ever now that I am the mother of a crazy toddler) the food was delicious and there was a notation on the menu that you can ask for more traditional dishes and they will accommodate, which is great. They have weekly deals that are posted on the website, so that's worth checking out.

tonycluber  on  Club 23

posted on 13 July, 2014
Joined 5 years ago
116 comments posted

After reading an inaccurate, mean-spirited review for Ornella on here recently, I wanted to update this to add that I've probably been there about a dozen times now despite living about 45 minutes away, and I love Ornella more than ever!If you want good quality, delicious food in a friendly environment, Ornella is definitely the place to go. Ignore the jerks on here! I've never had a bad meal at Ornella, and Giuseppe and his family are wonderful hosts.

Kaity B.  on Club 23

posted on 13 July, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I gotta say, I think some of the 1 star reviewers are either crazy, illiterate or just have misguided expectations. I've been here three times, most recently last Thursday and the food is as good as it gets. I've never had something here that I didn't love and the same goes for my husband. We went with an amazon deal...$50 of food and drink for $25 and our voucher was accepted without question.It's a beautiful restaurant, the service is always friendly and prompt (also, who really cares if there are two waiters taking care of you if you get your food faster??) I wish I lived closer so I could come more often.

Margaret C.  on Club 23

posted on 4 July, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I have to agree with Will B, people just take themselves too seriously sometimes. Who knows what the real circumstances are; it's always a he said/she said situation. But I can tell you I have known Guiseppe and his family for over 20 years and he is as honest as the day is long; he believes in the honor of hospitality and the best possible service to his guests. I have eaten at Ornella at least twice a month since he opened and have NEVER had a bad meal or bad service! I think it is quite honorable that he takes the time to answer his critics with what I believe to be truth with a touch of humor. Ornella is one of my favorite restaurants -- I love the food, ambiance and the people who so lovingly make you feel like a special guest in their home.

Astha T.  on Club 23

posted on 26 June, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

been here few times and every time the food has been amazing, the burrata and imbustata is my fav here but every dish here is pretty good. the staff is always friendly and warm...

Emily C.  on Club 23

posted on 19 June, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

In any big city, it can feel impossible to find an eatery that resonates with the warmth of an inviting neighborhood spot where, as the stereotype goes, everyone know your name. Still, this is the place.My dear sister and her husband live, die and swear by Ornella and I finally understand why. The food is painstakingly handmade (pasta! pizza! really, all the Italian staples), the wine pours are heavy, and the owners and servers are amazingly friendly. So much so that my sister (who lives in Queens and has been coming here for years) is so enthusiastically greeted and made to feel like family every time she walks through the doors - and that also extends to her own family (hence why I love the place)I've eaten at Ornella several times and each has been a downright wonderful experience. The gnocchi is always melt-in-your-mouth outstanding, tiramisu is the best I've had, and the duck meatballs are beautifully stuffed with mozzarella and bathed in a tangy orange sauce. The pasta di castagna is another marvelous specialty, made of homemade chestnuts flour pasta with arugula, cherry tomatoes in garlic & oil sauce. Specials change regularly and are always worth a look. Can't wait to return!

Joyce F.  on Club 23

posted on 12 June, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

food was interesting and good.A little more expensive than anticipated but i would go back

rogerrab2  on  Club 23

posted on 11 June, 2014
Joined 4 years ago
100 comments posted

Had a groupon, no restrictions an the menu, has the codfish with mash potato and linguine with seafood, it was amazing, also had the belvedere salad and fried calamari, and it was great too, my husband and I will definitely go back, groupon or no groupon!

Emilie O.  on Club 23

posted on 11 May, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I enjoyed the pasta specials on Thursdays, just like happy hours for pasta, but love, love, loved the pizza! The dough was perfectly baked both time I was there!The waiter tends to be invisible most of the time (I think he wraps the delivery orders), but he comes back to check your table enough times.

StripClub431  on  Club 23

posted on 24 April, 2014
Joined 4 years ago
94 comments posted

Came here easter sunday for dinner. The pork pappardelle must have been sitting out for a while before arriving at our table. The noodles were stuck together and the sauce was dry. The duck meatballs must have shrunk because they were smaller than the posted pics and they were hard. I thought meatballs were supposed to be tender and juicy. Will definitely not return. What a waste of money. I'm embarassed for them.

Tony C.  on Club 23

posted on 21 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Ornella Trattoria is my kind of Italian restaurant-the ones that doesn't just serve spaghetti and meatballs or baked zitis. Each dish is unique and provokes interest. Broccoli di Rape ($8.00) - Plenty of garlic flavor but was a bit tough and old. (7/10)Spade alla livornese ($23.00) - A sauteed swordfish steak in tomato sauce. I was really excited to swordfish but the texture wasn't to my liking. Swordfish meat is quite firm and had the flavor and texture similar to tuna/salmon. However the sauce was great, helped but the addition of capers. (7/10)Linguine di mare ($22.00) - Seemed to be the most popular dish that night. A medley of seafood (clams, mussels. calamari) on linguine. The clams packed intense seafood flavor and there were very generous with the squid and museels. The broth was light in flavor. (8/10)Although delicious, the experience was disappointing as each dish took forever to get to the table. On a Monday night, the restaurant was packed but unfortunately there was only one chef doing the cooking according to the waiters. It took half a hour before our appetizers arrived and a hour before our entrees were served.

Adriana A.  on Club 23

posted on 20 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Ornella is by far my favorite Italian restaurant in Astoria! What I luv about ornella is that you can always count on having a great meal. No need to even look at the menu bc Giuseppe will always recommend the freshest dishes according to your mood and taste. To start I Always order the white bean and shrimp appetizer w/ rosemary and garlic. It is so simple and aromatic you have to be careful cuz you'll eat the entire thing by yourself. For entree i recommend you order the envelope atleast once! It is sooo good and unique I can't even describe it. Their vegetarian menu is designed for everyone specially his chestnut pasta. But my ultimate favorite it's his fish francese. I crave it all the time! It is an explosion of citrus, butter and flaky fish in your mouth! You can have it w a side of fresh pasta or delicious veggies. I seriously stop by ornella everytime I come home from a long trip. Giuseppe always makes my belly happy to have arrived. Enjoy your meal :)

Heather R.  on Club 23

posted on 16 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Despite living a block away I had never been here before this past Saturday and can promise that I never will again. I am so embarrassed for asking my family to drive in from Long Island for the experience we encountered here. My family arrived this past Saturday night for my parents 28th wedding anniversary; we were looking to try a new place and the $50 for $25 advertised groupon and proximity to my apartment was enticing. Upon our timely arrival for our 7:30 reservation we were told we couldn't be seated for 20-30 minutes. Good thing I made a reservation? I left my phone number with the owner and told him to call when a table was ready as we went to a bar around the corner for drinks. At 8:10 (40 minutes later) the phone call was received and we headed immediately back as we were quite hungry at this point. We placed our orders and proceeded to wait a good 25-30 minutes until our salad was served, asking our waiter to refill our drinks a couple times as no notice was taken. Dinner took equally as long and when the owner came to our table to ask how we were enjoying everything my uncle was honest that the food was good (nothing I'd write home about however) but the service/fact that we had to wait so long for our reservation was uncalled for and extremely unprofessional. Rather than apologizing or trying to make up for the terrible first impression by offering any form of compensation: dessert for my parents (we'd made mention it was their anniversary for the nothing that it was worth), glass of wine, etc. he was rudely defensive and assured us the restaurant is not always like this. Just our luck I suppose?As if the dining experience was not enough, when it came to paying the check our experience worsened. My uncle surrendered his credit card to pay the bill. After another 10-15 minutes of waiting for that and the receipt to be returned we were more than tired of spending our evening waiting and decided to walk up to the bar to sign the check and leave. Upon arrival at the front we came to find what was taking so long was that my uncle's CREDIT CARD WAS LOST. After 20 minutes of searching and my uncle's frantic phone calls attempting to cancel his account one of the busboy's found it in the sink! The owner, once again, offered us nothing for wasting our time but rather remarked that he "didn't think our first experience was an enjoyable one." What an astute observation, sir!First impressions are lasting ones, and this will most certainly stick with me for a VERY long time. My family has officially disallowed me from choosing restaurants ever again, sorry for ruining your anniversary mom & dad.

Melissa L.  on Club 23

posted on 10 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Ronald G.  on Club 23

posted on 1 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I am torn on this place. It essentially comes down to that the food is great but the service is mediocre at best.Food: Some of the better Italian food in Astoria. I've had the chicken parm, various pastas, and the pepper steak and they were all quite good and fresh.starter bread was stale once which is not acceptable so -1 star for that.Minus a second star for service. We usually end up getting the same waiter each time. I think it is the owner's son. He never really looks happy to be there and grudgingly brings out the food and takes the orders. Maybe he should look into doing something else?Price is OK, they have run Amazon Local, Groupon, and other deals in the past as well.

Tam s.  on Club 23

posted on 31 March, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Overall, it was pretty disappointing. We were not impressed with the Risotto del mare. The duck meatballs were over cooked, hard and dried. And we did not enjoy the chestnut pasta . The only thing we enjoyed was the Broccoli di Rape, I would give that a four stars. Everything else is a one star. And it took exactly 55 minutes for our first order of appetizer to arrive. We normally don't like to rush through dinner, but to wait 55 minutes for the order of appetizer to come out is a bit much. Finished all our wine without any appetizer to go with.

Sarah D.  on Club 23

posted on 22 February, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Came here for Valentine's Day and was extremely disappointed. The calamari was barely fried and kind of tasteless. Asked for more water and never got any. Asked for the check, never got it and asked again - someone finally dropped it off after waiting 20 minutes and asking twice. Gave the waiter my credit card and waited another 20 minutes and it never came back. I had to ask a waiter for my credit card back - the whole process of paying took close to 40 minutes, despite that they had a huge crowd of people waiting for a table. Expensive considering the poor service and mediocre food. I will not be going back.

Michael D.  on Club 23

posted on 6 February, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

The place had a nice homely feeling but that was the only positive thing about it. We sat down to a table were brought bread but no plates or utensils. Had to ask for butter twice. Was really craving Calamari but they had none. DO NOT ADD SHRIMP TO ANY PASTA!!! WAS ONLY SERVED 2 SHRIMPS CUT IN HALF TO RESEMBLE FOUR PIECES!!! Waiters kept forgetting to come back with more water and took my girlfriends knife and and did not bring a new one when asked twice for one. Save your money and eat at home...

AssnTits5  on  Club 23

posted on 13 January, 2014
Joined 9 years ago
171 comments posted

My wife and I purchased a voucher from Amazon for this place because we had passed by it several times and wanted to check it out. I had read some of the reviews on here before we went and I wasn't really sure what to expect. Some people really like the food, others said it was just ok. After first hand experience, it was nothing to write home about, it was just ok. I had the Penne con Polo, which was chicken with penne pasta in a cream sauce. There was just something that was missing from the dish. I don't know if it was the lack of salt or other spices but it just didn't really satisfy my palate. My wife ordered the sea bass special. She said the fish was cooked well but the sauce was very acidic and the pasta on the side barely had any flavor. The service was horrible. The one waiter that works here either didn't get trained properly or just doesn't care about his job. After we were reviewing the menu for a few minutes, he comes by and asks abruptly if we're ready. He takes our order and then goes back to the bar to play on his phone. He just seemed like he couldn't be bothered to be there. During the whole interaction with us I think he said about 4 words. After we got the bill, there was a remaining balance of $10 after the voucher was deducted. I gave the waiter my credit card but he told me that he won't take the card because he will get charged a fee by the credit card company. Unfortunately, I didn't have any cash on me so I walked outside to the nearest ATM. I didn't make a big deal about the situation but my wife and I were quite upset about how rude he dealt with us. In end, we decided we wouldn't return back to this establishment. I can get over the bad service if the food is amazing. Unfortunately, this place lacked in both categories. The owner is quick to reply to any negative comments that customers write on here but he should spend that time in fixing the issues at his restaurant. If you don't know by now, you need to cater to making your customers happy and then you would have a lot of 5 stars.

Scarlette T.  on Club 23

posted on 11 December, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

unremarkable. i was so incredibly excited to come here and we tried the "home of the duck meatballs and chestnut pasta" specials. the meatballs, tasted like, well, meatballs. they were more moist than standard meatballs. and there was nothing bad about it, but nothing good. seasoning was unspectacular, the sauce it was swimming in was gooey and unspecial. perhaps they were having an off night. the chestnut pasta with pistachio sauce was tough. did not taste like fresh pasta at all. wasn't cooked properly. sauce was bland. the wine was good (nicholas pinot).we ordered the belvedere salad and the mozzarella special (which is swimming in arugula with the same spiced walnuts, someone should've told us how redundant that was). actually, a little risque, but i'd actually put the mozzarelle on the belvedere salad and take out the gorgonzola (which always ruins everything in my book).the short ribs were the most decent thing there. gnocchi was alright. i should have just ordered the pappardelle with ragu instead of the duck and chestnut pasta. though i am giving two stars, i do actually hope to be back to try some other items. but again, there are so many restaurants out there. why let one break your heart (or stomach) twice?other notes: it is incredibly dark in there as well. candles = open flames, watch your sleeves! service was very good once we got settled. they were on top of us the whole night and made sure we had all we needed to nosh away. and their tiramisu is very good with the pinot that we had. they have some interesting things on their dessert menu: i swear i read raisins in their ricotta cheesecake. O_o?

Khim G.  on Club 23

posted on 1 December, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Ordered the fried calamari and return because we could not eat/chew it due to being overcooked and very rubbery. Very disappointing esp. after 30 minutes of waiting. Maybe that was why it was cooked overly? Worst thing was the owner still wanted us to pay for it as he was claiming that there was nothing wrong with it. Well, he just could not admit that such thing happens and nobody is perfect. Much worst than that was when he told us that if we didn't want to pay, just leave and don't come back. What a very unprofessional restaurant owner who doesn't have a customer service trait.

Charlie L.  on Club 23

posted on 9 November, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Really good little neighborhood spot. Owner knows his stuff and is a great host. The food is always delicious, the service is solid, and the price is right.

Maria K.  on Club 23

posted on 26 October, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

The food is absolutely delicious! Thursdays is $10 pasta night and anything off of that menu is simply yummy!

Chris C.  on Club 23

posted on 17 October, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Sometimes Saturday Night Live comes to you. In our never ending quest to find a hidden gem with great steak and affordable prices, my girlfriend and I happened upon this little spot in Ditmars. Guess what we ordered, steaks. I got the au poivre, she the porterhouse. The base steak for the au poivre wasn't anything that great. The porterhouse was a bit better, having a bit more flavor to it. The service though was unintentionally entertaining. The staff of about 4 guys in their mid to late twenties had a charming dysfunction that fell somewhere between Steve Martin's 'Absent Minded Waiter' and the restaurant skits from Sandler, Schneider, Farley, Meyers et al. Overall, while the steaks were not the gems we were looking for, the experience was pleasant. We might not return for a while, but that is only because we're on a mission, to find a great affordable steak in New York.

Jeffrey L.  on Club 23

posted on 4 October, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Came here with a group of four and the food was great. This restaurant has a very great ambiance, perfect for a romantic date or a quiet outing with a small group of friends. We came here on a Thursday night for their $10 Pasta Special. I ordered the Penne Bolognese and it was very well made. Pasta was cooked al dente and sauce was delicious. We also order fried calamari, the squid was fresh, but not as crispy as I expected. The pasta was well-portioned and according to the manager/owner, they serve the same amount of pasta as they would have if you paid full price, which is a great deal because full price is around $16-$20. Would definitely come back here to try their other pastas. They also have a steak special night on Mondays for $15 steak.

Lauren E. M.  on Club 23

posted on 3 October, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I went back, and the place smelled super clean and like good Italian food! Also, my friend and I sat at our table forever chatting and even though our total bill was incredibly inexpensive, the manager came over and gave us a (HUGE!) glass of wine on the house. I'll definitely be back.

Mohammed R.  on Club 23

posted on 21 September, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Though some of the reviews I saw were helpful nothing could help this poor establishment. Food was flavorless, waiters seemed unprofessional with snickering (making jokes) and most importantly the meals didn't seemed genuinely Italian but rather out of Chef Boyardees can. The owner attempts to show interests but the extended wait time for the entrees superseded his efforts. I do no recommend this location to anyone who enjoys good traditional Italian cuisine.

Jamal S.  on Club 23

posted on 31 August, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Chicken Dish with bones is no test @ all, I had t bone with pasta that was ok, Servers are Friendly . Excellent Service . But they need to improve their food .

Amy A.  on Club 23

posted on 2 August, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I've been to Ornella twice now with my family and we have all enjoyed our meals both times! I have nothing bad to say about this restaurant - the talkative owner made us feel comfortable. The atmosphere was pleasant. I highly recommend the pear salad - my mom and I loved it! They cater to gluten-free needs, too, which is rare for Italian restaurants (at no additional cost!) I was thrilled to be able to get gluten-free pasta with my fish. We'll be back!

Natalie N.  on Club 23

posted on 2 July, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

This is the most disgusting Italian food I have ever had. I ordered the Rigatoni Matriciana with extra sauce and sausage. The sauce was a nasty tasteless watery substance. The food was Luke warm and it really looked like the chef may have done something nasty to it. I threw it away and got my money back. Some of the reviews on here are really shocking, or perhaps those people have never been exposed to authentic Italian food. There is nothing authentic about this place. You would think the owner would do something to fix the problem, but instead he says order from another place. Having lived in Astoria for more than 10 years, I don't see this place lasting much longer. If you are a real foodie and know what GOOD food taste like, I would avoid this place at all costs.

Joyce T.  on Club 23

posted on 29 May, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Friend wanted to have italian. We passed by Ornella and it looked like a family kind of italian place, so we decided to give it a try. The bread was stale. I love the bread at Italian places and usually I ask for more. But at Ornella, if it weren't balsamic vinegar, I couldn't have finished one slice of the bread. Friend ordered gnocchi alla gorgonzola. He liked it and was surprised with the big portion. I had sea food spaghetti which was ok. The sauce was kinda bland. The shrimp was good. The calamari in the dish was all the end of calamari, no middle part (ring), guess they save the calamari rings for something else. The mussels were small, not fresh. The waiter slipped the plate and made a loud noise when the plate hit the glass. They gave us a complimentary cake which wasn't very good, lots of frosting and soggy cake. Till today, friend and I still don't know what dessert it was.

Maria R.  on Club 23

posted on 20 May, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I am not sure where to start...I absolutely love Ornella Trattoria. I celebrate my special occasions here, I look forward to a special date night with my boyfriend because I know we'll go there, I take my family there when they're in New York to visit. Basically, whenever it has to be just right...I go to Ornella. Ornella & Giuseppe Viterale have poured their love and care into this restaurant. You will know this is not just another neighborhood restaurant from your warm greeting at the door; the home made bread, Giuseppe's enthusiastic descriptions of the inventive and absolutely delicious new creations, the service, the wines, the buzzing atmosphere...The Orecchiette con Rape (Ear-shaped pasta with broccoli rape & sundried tomatoes from the Vegetarian Menu) is my favorite meal at Ornella, but there is nothing I've ever had there I didn't love. I have worked in the luxury hotel business for over 20 years and dined in some of the city's most renowned restaurants. I can honestly say when choosing a restaurant for my own enjoyment, I choose Ornella...for the food, for the special care, for new interesting dishes and to patronize a creative and innovative small business with a big heart. I recommend Ornella wholeheartedly. Try it - you won't be disappointed!

Previous Page123Next Page

Share This Page