Fickle Filly Comments

2.3

23814 Linden Blvd

Elmont, New York 

28,341 Views116 Comments  

charles  on Fickle Filly

posted on 8 January, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

did fickle filly closed in elmont? if so where is the new location

just a guy  on Fickle Filly

posted on 21 September, 2011
This comment was posted anonymously

Can anyone tell me who the best girl to hang with is. Im tired of hags. I prefer daytime..

FRANKENBERRY  on Fickle Filly

posted on 16 January, 2011
This comment was posted anonymously

The stories of the filly's demise are not true.....at least not now......... the lease has been extended until april.. the filly and all the girls are alive and kicking!!!!!

hary  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 May, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

madelines doesnt work anymore and she is engaged so i dont think you have a chance

Mets FanII  on Fickle Filly

posted on 3 May, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

Does anyone know if madeline works anywhere else. I would like to see her, but don't have any contact info. on her. Any help would be appreciated, thanks.

stevie your the loser  on Fickle Filly

posted on 29 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

keep trying dude.. Better bring roll of $$

Mets FanII  on Fickle Filly

posted on 28 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

I heard maddy had a arguement with a girl. Is she def. not coming back?

sunday regular  on Fickle Filly

posted on 27 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

truth about madeline she gives awsome lap dances yes she will jerk you and give you ataste and maybe more get her drunk

a regular  on Fickle Filly

posted on 27 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

shes not working here anymore .

Mets FanII  on Fickle Filly

posted on 21 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

when can i find madeline. What day and shift?

a regular  on Fickle Filly

posted on 17 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

you guys are talking about the spanish girl black hair i had a lap dance from her too it was great can feel her everywhere tastes good too

old fillygoer  on Fickle Filly

posted on 14 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

yes shes back i had the best lap dance from her wear loose pants and get her drunk she wont dissapoint you can meet her after hours. think she works sun and monaday

hary  on Fickle Filly

posted on 3 April, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

i here madeline is back and as good as ever any truth to this

stevielove  on Fickle Filly

posted on 25 March, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

you fucking assholes. Isabella has a bit too much class for you huh? Wouldn't give you the right time of day asshole, grow up losers.

hairy  on Fickle Filly

posted on 23 February, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

anyone seen or know where madelines works

dead beat  on Fickle Filly

posted on 10 February, 2009
This comment was posted anonymously

nice club, girls are always friendly, day time relaxed atmosphere, older crowd always a good time

Big Man  on Fickle Filly

posted on 31 December, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Hey Johnni you are wrong about Isabella, she is married, and is dating two guys now.....and so forth LOL !

BIG BOY  on Fickle Filly

posted on 19 December, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Hey when is Isabella working again, I'llbe her BF.....shit I am loaded ...I 'll gladly pay her bills for some cozy companionship.. :).. Isabella if you catch this post, , postthe day you you work.....i will be there :)

johnny  on Fickle Filly

posted on 12 November, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

isabella has no boyfriends she dates four different guys to pay her bills, she also works in the city my buddy saw here there.. the place is a dump dont waste your time at the ff

old customer  on Fickle Filly

posted on 12 November, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

id never go 2 this dump again since they fired 1 of there best looking girls mystik is gone isabella is only a bartender and soon 2 b gone if her new boyfriend has a say in it.. by the way did vicky get any teeth yet she might wanna hurry up i heard the pl has no cabaret lsc n will b shut down soon..

BOI  on Fickle Filly

posted on 17 October, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

this bar sucks all old brazilian hags...really bad......

new to the bar  on Fickle Filly

posted on 15 October, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Paula is a sweet heart what other days does she work esides wends.

new customer  on Fickle Filly

posted on 12 October, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Paula is great any info on her

fred  on Fickle Filly

posted on 2 September, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

any info on Lori- the bartender? I think she's hot!Does she fool around at all?

to Gary re smooth  on Fickle Filly

posted on 23 August, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

She loves to have her pussy played with. I was fingering the shit out of he sitting by the bar and then on stage. The only problem is her pussy stinks. She offered to meet me on the outside. Get her wet first by rubbing her pussy on the outside of her thong before slipping it aside to finger her. Try to wash your hands before you get home.

gary  on Fickle Filly

posted on 20 August, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Whats the deal with smooth??

BUSSOWNER  on Fickle Filly

posted on 29 June, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

I was there about a week ago . They have new great looking girls The place is a great hangout bar.

Finance Man  on Fickle Filly

posted on 30 January, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Hey does anyone know if Jackie(from Candlewood ) work here. She is a very shapely Brazilian lady. I am trying to locate her....she has a pretty daughter that used to work at L'OFFina in Corona.........anyone knows where she is too??

Under New Management  on Fickle Filly

posted on 8 January, 2008
This comment was posted anonymously

Watch for the new signs out front. Same pathetic losers running the place. The guy who yells at the bartenders that they pour too much booze. The brunette with the missin teeth that fires all the good dancers. Karen who looked at her ex. Mystik who said sumthin bad about her new boyfriend. Madeline who did coke with the new boyfriend. Dob't worry. the skinny blond skank will still be their to rob you n da house blind.

to Mystic  on Fickle Filly

posted on 8 November, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

you were, are, and always will be a trashy prostitute.....

mystik  on Fickle Filly

posted on 8 September, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

OMG.........I found mystik I was doin biz in the bx n decided 2 check out this spot now I use 2 c mystik mon nights @ the filly n although black chicks r my thing her fatt ass n personality keep my attention she was a great pool player n shit talker as well as bein sexy...so she's now a bartender in the bx I don't know if she dances anymore I didn't get 2 ask I was amazed 2 c her she looks great don't know her schedule either I was drafted away by some luscious chick 4 a LD anyway mystik fans I found her she's @ crazy horse....seen a few other filly gooers there also so 4 those who don't know she's there and amazing as ever

Game Man  on Fickle Filly

posted on 31 August, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

to the last post regarding Isabella ....it is true......she is a great girl......but she will work out something with you on the outside...when it comes to the Benjamins..... I do not want to degrade he.....becasue she is a dynamite girl....but she is a "whore" in bed...love it....... she need st o get away from Fickle..that place is diseased... :)

NSloan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 23 August, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

What night does Isabella dance...what kind of scene is this joint, I was thinking of swinging by for a bit on a thursday or friday night

james  on Fickle Filly

posted on 21 August, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

I thought Isabella did since she is 50. But, they are real.. She gives the best BJ. Give her a couple benjis and she will work it out when she gets off..

FILLIE DEATH SPIRAL  on Fickle Filly

posted on 16 August, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

It's speeding up. If you stay on, look out for the crash!!

NSloan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 12 August, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Any girls with implants at this club? thanks

BQE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 11 August, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Sad to say you guys are right about Isabella. one day the door was open and daylight came in. man she is getting old! in the dark club looks nothing like how she looks in daylight. plus she will tell you all about her real estate empire. at first sounds like all that hard work giving lap dance hard ons but turn out she has been scamming guys especially ex husbands and soon to be ex husbands for years. Isabella jesus freak lets bow our heads in prayer and while our eyes are closed you can reach into the next guys pockets.

Joe  on Fickle Filly

posted on 22 July, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

How do I hook up with Isabella?

HOW COME?  on Fickle Filly

posted on 13 July, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

How come they never fire the ugly girls?

Tomtom  on Fickle Filly

posted on 29 June, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Paula is back and as good as ever. Friday night had some hot new girls.

RE: Isabella  on Fickle Filly

posted on 12 June, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

She has been around the block doing this for years. She use to work at Gallaghers scaming guys there. Good thing she didn't call you back. Some of the other girls at the club told me she scams guys all the time to pay her bills. Sleeps with a bunch of guys at the club now who all gives her money

We miss MYSTIK  on Fickle Filly

posted on 8 June, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

She was back this week, she is getting soooo old. Don't waste your money on her.. She gave me her number to go on a date, asked me for money.. Mystik was the BEST!!!!!

Help  on Fickle Filly

posted on 6 June, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Is Isabella still here? When?

Vickie the dancer  on Fickle Filly

posted on 6 May, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

What happened to Vickie the tall skinny Brazilian dancer??

MIss this place  on Fickle Filly

posted on 18 April, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

We miss this place...When we are down next we will def. be stopping by to visit. Is paula still around?? She was such a sweetheart.

bob  on Fickle Filly

posted on 9 April, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

vickie was hot.....15 yrs ago. please dont dance on stage any more vickie!!

BQE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 26 March, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Fickle Filly death spiral. Used to be OK, then they fired Mystik. Then Mystik's fans stopped coming. Mystik's fans also tipped tip out girls, so the good looking tip out girls stopped coming. So customers who liked tip out girls stopped coming. Its in the Vulcan death grip downward spiral now. Last time I went was at night one girl past out drunk on stage and like two customers. Daytime not much better. Its sad this place used to be sooo much fun.

jay  on Fickle Filly

posted on 18 March, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

this place has the oldest and ugliest girls in the whole NY area. And I am not that demanding either. A request to ownership: get some decent talent or people will never come back; anyone better tha a "3" would do.

Paula  on Fickle Filly

posted on 11 March, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Paula is back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Happy Birthday.  on Fickle Filly

posted on 15 February, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Vickie... Today's your birthday. Sorry I couldn't be there personally, but I hope you have a special, happy day.

Hi Crystal  on Fickle Filly

posted on 12 February, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

We know its you. Why are you so obsessed with Mystik?

To Anybody???  on Fickle Filly

posted on 11 February, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Are you so upset that your boobs have dropped? Or, are you just mad that you can't get the "sympathy tip" from Mystik's followers? Grow up. Get a life.

Erin  on Fickle Filly

posted on 6 February, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

Started going to this club about a month ago, first time there i walked out disgusted and dissapointed. I decided to try it again after that and fell in love with the place. Have been going weekly now, there are some really run down girls but there are a few good ones mixed in, very relaxing enviroment, get plenty 1 on 1 time with the girls.

To anybody  on Fickle Filly

posted on 5 February, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

please post where shytstik is so we can go over to the club and let the owners know what a piece of shit asshole is and then call narcotics and see how long her new club will be pleased with her with all the police activity she brings. No club wants to deal with that. We`ll start with Rouge, heard she was spotted there...hmm?

This is Mystik  on Fickle Filly

posted on 2 February, 2007
This comment was posted anonymously

It must be a bad feeling to be getting old and having your boobs and ass sink. I no longer work there. I wasnt there for three months yet you still talk about me. Get a life. Stop obsessing over me. I moved on, and I am happy. To those of you who are true friends, send me a text or call and ill tellyou where I am at.

Wassuppp  on Fickle Filly

posted on 21 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Perfect place to go to with sweat pants with the pockets cut out.Used to be real great on fridays but they got rid of the pretty ones to make room for da drunks n skanks. at least your odds are bettr now

Another Mystik fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 17 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

In other news, the Manhattan fastfood restarant, Gray's Papaya, has decided to stop selling hot dogs. The owner told reporters that he believed the restarant would be able to continue making profits by selling other products. Seriously, what a fucking idiotic decision to fire the best dancer, entertainer, barmaid, a person who was not just beautiful but very funny and nice to talk to. Please, please, other Mystik fans, keep us informed and tell us where she is working, we will follow her there.

Mystik..  on Fickle Filly

posted on 14 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

The only dancer and barmaid worth going there for! Other then her, the place is a dump!

BYE BYE MYSTIK  on Fickle Filly

posted on 14 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Question---what idiot would get rid of their only number one star? answer--- the jealous one.

BUSSOWNER&CREW  on Fickle Filly

posted on 13 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

!!!!!!!!!!!!!! mystik is no longer working here !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! what a looser the owner of this join is to let go the best dancer he had.... well as for me and my crew we are no longer going there and all mystik fan club has moved we will keep you posted. as for this place the new rating is -000000 ffffff the rating previously posted was mine sorry this place now sucks sorry john this was the worst business decision you ever made. money is the reason we have a business. and in your case is the dancer that makes your business the one who you take care of. hope she never comes back so you learn your lesson!!!!! ps we love you mystik //you are the best

George  on Fickle Filly

posted on 9 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

This place blows. I was there last night. Some black girl was passed out sleeping on the stage. There was a white girl and all she was doing was getting drunk. Total waste of time and the place is a shithole.

BUSSOWNER&CREW  on Fickle Filly

posted on 6 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

!!!!!!!!!!!!happy birthday mystik!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! what can we say: the party was excellent 2 dj's the food/the music the girls!! and mystik look amazing there was no words to describe how good she looks. she is the woman of our dreams/love that smiles. as for me and my crew we are grateful she works there so we can see her but rest assure that she will be followed anywhere she is the best!..... i think that i and my crew am now the official: !!!!! mystik fanclub!!!!!!!! we love you

Question?  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

It looks like the only reason to go to this place is for Mystik? Anything else to offer? What about the other dancers? Also, heard the place is a bit of a dump? Why does she work there if she's so HOT!

Fillie Fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Did you make the party? Well, let me tell you, it started out a little slow but when it got pumping it just got good. A great time was had by all who came. And in case anyone was wondering... the birthday girl looked MAHVELOS!!! Not bad at all.

Fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 1 November, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Come in on Friday for Mystik's birthday party. If you don't have a good time here on Friday, you're gay!!!

Joe  on Fickle Filly

posted on 31 October, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

I heard some of the girls provide extra's after hours. Any truth to this?

DUMP  on Fickle Filly

posted on 28 October, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

This place is the ultimate dive. I need a tetanus shot just looking at this dump!!!!

LKG70  on Fickle Filly

posted on 28 October, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

There are two words to say about mystik. HOT AND SMOKING! I've seen her dance with that lucious shapley sexy body on friday's and now I came in on a mondayand saw her beautiful form behind the bar. She informed me she also tends bar on sunday day time as well. Mystik is beyond words. Come by this establishment and see for yourself!

jimmy DD  on Fickle Filly

posted on 26 October, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Not worth it...no lap dances, , , all you do is watch them on stage and give them dollar bills....if theyhad lap danvesand private roons this place would be mcuh much better

BUSSOWNER&CREW  on Fickle Filly

posted on 22 October, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Great Place to hang out Friendly Bar maids Vicky and Nancy are nice and fun and let us not forget the Beautiful MYSTIC witch happens to be my favorite bar maid and Dancer.I got there by co-worker invitation and let me tell you. This is my favorite place. The best of all is MYSTIC and that is not only my opinion since I get to go there every Friday with my crew of workers. If you love fun and friendly people this is the place for you. But don't forget our favorite day is Friday since MYSTIC is there and she is the best funny and great overall entertainer that last 1/2 hour is mine. So come in early. Enjoy your visit as for me and my crew We will be there every MYSTICDAY I mean Friday.

COCHISE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 22 October, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

The best thing in there is mystik, my god she is a goddess on this earth. she is what a dancer is suppose to be . soo if your in the area go check her

NONAME  on Fickle Filly

posted on 23 August, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

The girls are all wonderful real people not plastic the regular barmaids linny lori vickie and nancy are fabulous and great to hang with always good energy

AC  on Fickle Filly

posted on 8 August, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

I saw Isabella last nite at the Candlewood.........its her new spot on Mon & Tues.........she is an awsome girl and lapdancer. Very cool to sit with and chill

FF  on Fickle Filly

posted on 31 July, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Where did they get the people that work at this place? Never saw so many unattractive people in one place at the same time! Dancers! Barmaids! Customers! Place needs a makeover!

HO HO HO  on Fickle Filly

posted on 30 May, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Mistik is a .........!......!......!

New To The Area  on Fickle Filly

posted on 31 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Stopped in the other day, place is a dump. Can't they find better looking people to work there!

BQE ??  on Fickle Filly

posted on 26 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Hey i do know Isa and Mystik, and yes they are not lesbo possibly bisexual...but I Isa she is a great gal......muuuaahh

New to the area  on Fickle Filly

posted on 25 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

for real, no joke. A BIG TIME DUMP.

New To The Area  on Fickle Filly

posted on 24 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

After reading a few of the posts, not sure if this is a dump or not. Anybody, want to be honest. What about the dancers? Friendly? Staff? Friendly?

BQE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 22 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

The last post under the name BQE is not by me the real BQE. It is probably Insider who steals everyones names to confuse things. And no Mystik is not lesbian and neither is Isabella. Mystik does not have a jealous boyfried either. Insider you are an ass.

Fillie Fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 14 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Alright now. Don't get all upset. Tell you what I'm going to do... I'll ask the dancer to give back your two dollars so your mother won't be mad at you for being irresponsible. but you have to promise that you learned your lesson. O.K. now?

To Fillie Fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 14 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

go see a doctor you sound like that place looks

Fillie Fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 13 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

How many screen names do you losers have? Mystik is a good entertainer. Isabella {retired for now} is a good entertainer. Paula and the others are good entertainers. Even you losers are good entertainers. Some of you by entering the bar, some of you by leaving the bar. If you like the place come in. If you don't, stay home.

BQE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 13 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

yes its true they were lovers (lesbos) but dont waste your hard earned money on Mystic because her boyfriend is very possessive and she likes that and caters to him so keep your money you wont get to first base with her....yes the place is a dump.

topless man  on Fickle Filly

posted on 13 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

i hear alot of good things about Mystik...in general. I know that someone once told me that Isabella (Gallaghers) and her were hot lovers and do a lot of crazy out going things......anyone knows if that is true...because i am willing to pay top dollars for a very big opportunity :))

Curious  on Fickle Filly

posted on 11 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Is this place a dump or not? Dancers? Barmaids?

WAKE THE FUCK UP  on Fickle Filly

posted on 7 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

yous are in a fuckin dump! Hello! any one home in there! stupids

BQE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 5 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Shytstik, I stand corrected, Insider, all the same person and now you are using Curious name too? So whoever you are let me politely tell you what you are: YOu are a fucking moron. You have insane hatred for Mystik who as Fillie Fan and Score pointed out is a great dancer and entertainer. Are you shocked she gets paid for it? Did you think she wanted to marry each customer and settle down? Because she is successful she is a hustler? You are to stupid for words and you are revealing yourself to be just a jealous probably other dancer

Curious  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Thanks for the info. Sounds like a hit and miss with the dancers. Are the barmaids HOT?

Insider  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Im not a dancer and of course shes the best one there, she would never be able to be in a place where real dancers are cause she wouldnt make the $$$$ thats why shes in a dump, where she knows she belongs.

Curious  on Fickle Filly

posted on 3 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

Heard a few things about this place, some say it a real dump others say it's an OK place to hang out. Any hot dancers? Barmaids?

The Score  on Fickle Filly

posted on 3 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

So insider, you admit that you work there, which means you are probably a dancer. So of course you're pissed off, because Mystik is the most popular and successful dancer there. Fillie Fan is right: She is a First Class Entertainer, a charmer, a beauty and a great dancer (unlike girls who just stand there like a deer caught in the headlights). So she gets paid to entertain. Duh! And that's what pisses you off right? That's why customers should not give her money, right? Maybe you'd be happier at a club with less competition.

Insider  on Fickle Filly

posted on 3 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

yeah shes everything smart club goers are sick of.....A HUSTLER only stupid doods that don't know any better are fooled. WAKE up dummies and stop giving Shit-stick your $$$$

Fillie Fan  on Fickle Filly

posted on 2 March, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

No matter how you feel about Mystik, you do have to admit that she is everything that she is supposed to be... and that is, a First Class Entertainer. Whether you like her or not, that is the fact. To quote Bond, "Nobody does it better".

insider  on Fickle Filly

posted on 28 February, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

im an insider honey, believe you, me

The Score  on Fickle Filly

posted on 28 February, 2006
This comment was posted anonymously

So Shytstik or whatever, you are an insider? Does that mean you work there? Only dancers, barmaids and a few bouncers work there. Sounds to me like you are not a customer and that English is not your first language.

toplessman  on Fickle Filly

posted on 10 August, 2005
This comment was posted anonymously

is that hot brazilian girl ..Isabella still there ??? Miss those unbelievable breasts :))

BQE  on Fickle Filly

posted on 30 May, 2005
This comment was posted anonymously

You gotta understand about this place: it has some of the butt uggliest dancers on planet earth, plus some of the finest, most sexy, beautiful dancers. Here are the animals, Patty (old, fat, drunk), Monet (the Austin Powers dancer -- "shes a man, baby!"). I would pay them to keep clothes on. I think owner hires them as charity like a old folks home for dancers. Gotta turn away when they start taking clothes off. But its worth it because of absolute perfect beuties, Mistik, Isabella, Paula, Jessica, Crystal. Lately a bunch of new pretty dancers are replacing the dinosaurs who are going extinct.

Why?  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 March, 2005
This comment was posted anonymously

If you arrive here with low expectations, you will not be disappointed.

Trashman  on Fickle Filly

posted on 4 March, 2005
This comment was posted anonymously

I hear Wednesday is 'OLD TIMERS DAY". Any truth?

Previous Page12Next Page

Share This Page