Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC Comments

4.2

320 West 45th Street

New York, New York 10036

146,278 Views595 Comments  

BlurryVision  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 12 February, 2018
This comment was posted anonymously

seats are too close to the stage, rename this place to Crossed-Eyes

Nial  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 3 October, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

Camilla still work days?

Joe  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 9 August, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

This place is a good time, nice girls, great all around strip club to chill with some of the sexiest girls in NYC, had a great time here, Thank You !!

scladmin (management)  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 25 July, 2017
Joined 2 years ago
362 comments posted

scladmin (management)  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 25 July, 2017
Joined 2 years ago
362 comments posted

scladmin (management)  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 25 July, 2017
Joined 2 years ago
362 comments posted

hiring hostesses and dancers

hiring hostesses and dancers

Click here to View Position

John  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 19 July, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

Has Priscilla and/or Carmen ever returned?

Curious  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 13 April, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

What happened to the skinny hot Asian.?

RobD  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 9 January, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

Camilla still work days?

Sophia  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 9 January, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

Yes...don't see her in the day anymore, heard she might be dancing nights.

Re: BeCareful  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 6 January, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

have you ever danced with Sophia?

BeCareful  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 4 January, 2017
This comment was posted anonymously

Stay away from that little hood rat Venus, she will rip you off every time...Why this club still allows her to work there is beyond me.....Overall great club, amazing girls....

Re: Question  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 December, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Anyone with Sophia info?

Question  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 14 November, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

is Sopfia still dancing in the night time?

Linda B.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 28 October, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

We ate here on our recent trip and it was excellent. It was after a show, so it was late. The steaks were perfect (medium) and the garlic mashed potatoes were to die for. The wait staff was so friendly and helpful and made this a very enjoyable experience.

Vince  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 29 September, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Man strip clubs get worse and worse . I used to be a big tipper but I found this camgirl on myfreecams - leeannstar and holy shit . Perfection in every way including personality which is like finding a fuckin unicorn. Just trying to help out my guys who might wanna give that a whirl . I included a pic . There's some aight girls on the site but none come close to this girl like NO way but its fun and they have raffles that you can win a date and shit too as well as the avn awards so its pretty cool

Re: Re: Re: SofiaStacey  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 27 September, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Sophia.................................Stacy??

Re: Re: SofiaStacey  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Sofia.............Stacey?

Re: Sofia  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 19 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Any info on Sofia, she looks fun?

staceythewaitress  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 11 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Stacey the waitress, is fine, any info?

Natalie J.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 6 August, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

I was extremely surprised to see an average rating of 3.5 for Frankie and Johnnies Steakhouse. I haven't been here for years but after my visit last week it's just as good as I remember. Has a very nice ambiance and is a great place for an after work gathering. Probably not the best place for a date night but the food makes it worth any gathering. If I were rating solely on food it'd be a 5 of 5.

Denise W.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 29 June, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

Ate here prior to the theater. My husband and I shared the Porterhouse for 2. Best steak in a very long time. Service was fantastic and owner stopped by to visit. What a story. We love that New York has so many long standing businesses and this is one of those!! Long standing businesses know what it takes to make customers happy. Such a great place to eat!

Les W.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 27 May, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

My friends were visiting NY from Tampa for the weekend. They asked me to pick a restaurant for dinner after seeing the show Sistas. I had been to Frankie and Johnnies in Rye and liked it so I made reservations via Opentable for 6 at the NY location which was a few doors down from the show.We arrived right after the show which was a little earlier than my reservation. We were seated immediately by the most beautiful hostess Caribell. We started off with drinks. I had the best Appletini of my life. It was so good I had to meet the bartender Lisa and thanked her personally. Our waiter Mario was very attentive. He made sure we had the right amount of appetizers and side dishes for the group. I had the Ribeye steak which was cooked medium well just as I ordered. It was delicious! Everyone else enjoyed their meal as well. At the end of the evening, Mario brought out a special dessert for my friends who were celebrating their anniversary. This was as much of a surprise to me as it was for them since I didn't remember mentioning it on my reservation. It was a great night out with good friends and good food. Thanks Mario, Claribell and Lisa for making it special.

geek  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 15 January, 2016
This comment was posted anonymously

do the dancers give bare footed dances here??

dannyboy7  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 17 December, 2015
Joined 2 years ago
52 comments posted

Worst steakhouse! We sat downstairs and the waitress who was serving us was so rude. Took over 30 minute to come over and acknowledge us. Took even longer to take our order. I had to stop her twice to ask for bread. She brought bread no butter and stormed always before I could ask for butter. Meal was the worst. The chicken was disgusting. Potatoes were bland. Never once came to refill our meal. For $100 I suggest you try so many other places in the area. Bad food. Bad service. Definitely DO NOT recommend.

Zachary R F.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 11 December, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Came here after a Broadway show and had a great steak dinner. Filet Mignon medium rare was not overly seasoned, it didn't need any steak sauce, the outside was lightly charred and crunchy, the inside was pink but not underdone, there was little to no fat and the juices were contained so there was never a dry bite. This is a traditional steakhouse, not really elegant or superficial and can be a little loud for a first date. The servers are very professional and reminded me of french butlers. The sides ($10-12 each) are huge for a midtown steakhouse. The spinach side is good for at least 3 people. My lady had the Salmon which was fresh, the perfect size and didn't taste fishy. I had a great experience here. We had 2 big salads (Caesar) , 3 sides (mushrooms,spinach,asparagus all delicious), the steak and salmon and the bill was $175 with tip (no alcohol).

Andrew M.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 11 December, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Great service, great food, great atmosphere upstairs in dining room. Otherwise pre-theatre dining experience top rate until I asked the surely female bartender downstairs where the ladies room was and she barked, "in the corner". Not unlike most square rooms there were 4 corners and when I inquired which corner she screamed " the one with the door and the light on". Perhaps, if there was a sign over the door (it is unisex, btw) she would not have to repeatly rudely answer the same question for newcomers. It is people like her who give NYC a bad name. Luckily I know better that she is just a frustrated miserable person who should not be working directly with customers.

Diane M.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 1 November, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

So my daughter, her godmother and godbrother and myself were out for a pre- show dinner. They had flown in from Cali to see Al Pacino's play. My friend decided to treat us to dinner. We were seated almost immediately. It was a bit uncomfortable as one patron, w his wife or lady friend just kind of glared at us. Nonetheless, we remained. Then there was sticker shock because the least expensive steak was around $45-- and that was a la carte. Everyone else ordered a sirloin and I got a ribeye. They were gorgeous and charred to perfection. My Caesar salad was delicious, tho a little heavy on dressing. Additionally, it had anchovies. Yum!! We all enjoyed our dinner, the ambience and our very attentive waiter. He was great. I will return here again-- no matter how hard I'm stared at!!!

yanard12  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 23 September, 2015
Joined 3 years ago
89 comments posted

Please don't let the 3 1/2 stars fool you because I almost did and that would've been a huge mistake. This place is wonderful. Upstairs is a little tight but the staff and food definitely make up for it. I loved the atmosphere and everyone (especially our waitress) was really friendly. The food was so delicious and we pretty much all but licked the plates. If you are in the area and want something authentic and less touristy that serves incredible food, please do yourself a favor and go here. It's totally worth it!

Norman S.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 7 June, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Yesterday I had the NY steak Prix Fixe luncheon for $25 which was extremely disappointing. The steak was not as good as Sizzler's and literally not much bigger than a silver dollar. The sides were steamed broccoli which was very good and sauteed potatoes which looked like overdone hash browns. I chose chocolate mousse for dessert which was terrible and was very bland.

Nigel  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 22 May, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

What is daytime like there now?

ryan123  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 1 April, 2015
Joined 9 years ago
181 comments posted

We didn't have a reservation so I think that was the first problem. We walked in and the snooty hostess told us she would have a table next to the bar in about ten minutes. Fifteen minutes later my 12 year old son and I were seated at a small and shaky pub table literally right next to the bar. There are four such tables. Ours was directly next to the coatrack and we were constantly disturbed and bumped into by the hostess (who was never off of her phone more than 60 seconds the entire night). Our "server" was the female bartender (Daniella, I think was her name). She was obviously flustered the entire night. She was also the bartender, bus boy and server for the first floor. She didn't take our order for 25 minutes. No water. No anything. She finally took our order and brought our drinks back about ten minutes later. She also brought us some bread, most of which was stale. It took an eternity for the food to arrive (chicken with mushrooms, a sirloin and fries). After we finished eating we waited for 20 more minutes for the check. For the price that we paid I would have hoped for a better experience. My son was happy with his steak but I thought that my chicken was mediocre at best. I wanted to treat my son to a special meal for his upcoming birthday and was very disappointed. I won't be returning. Shame because the place has such a cool history. It wasn't all the fault of the server as I believe she was more comfortable behind the bar slinging drinks. We tipped her well because I could see that she was struggling. During the show my son and I started getting rumbling bellies. Now that we're home both of us are sick to our stomachs. Not the experience that I wanted for his special day.

winston12  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 23 March, 2015
Joined 5 years ago
117 comments posted

Well.. As mentioned in other reviews the staff was not the friendliest, actually a bit standoffish. My husband ordered the petite filet medium well and it was delivered to our table well done! that was the last we saw of our server for the night! she past our table at least 7 times and never once stopped to ask us how our meal was. My husband said in spite of the steak being cooked more done than he would've liked, it was tasty. He also had the garlic mash potatoes which he really enjoyed. I settled for the wedge salad which was tasty for lettuce & a boatload of blue cheese. I did not get a good vibe and felt very uncomfortable at this restaurant. The food was decent but not to the caliber where I would go back for more snobby attitude. I will do my homework next time! Shout out to the bus person who kept my water glass filled though!

L Black  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 15 February, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Okay here goes i was a dancer for 12 years in the Houston Texas area. I worked several clubs now I'm a writer looking to find a entertainer and waitress. I have questions like how much are the drinks out there? Entertainer's how much is tipout? Waitresses what is your shift pay? I am working on my first novel & have hit a stump BC I never danced in New York. Any help would be greatly appreciated & credit would be given. 😁

Patricia M.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 25 January, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Fabulous! Very pleased with our entire dining experience. This was our second visit and will definitely return.

Derek D.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 6 January, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

I will try to keep this brief as this restaurant is not worth more than 5-10 minutes of my (or anyone's) time. We booked a table for 3 on New Year's Eve. Upon arrival we were asked if we'd like to check our coats, we declined citing cell phones, wallets, etc. in our coat pockets. The hostess replied something along the lines of "Well you'll have to because it is very small upstairs." Fine. We give her our coats and she puts them in the back corner of the barroom on what looks like a shower curtain rod. There's no proper cloak room to speak of.We're shown upstairs to the dining room, eat dinner, share a bottle of wine, and everything is all fine and good. Typical steakhouse fare served in a somewhat dingy, tired dining room.Upon leaving we find the hostess sitting at a table in the barroom eating a T-bone steak and mashed potatoes. Behind the bar is another woman who is literally shouting over and over again "F@!* these people!! God damn these people!! F@!*!! F@!*!!" venting some sort of frustration about something or other. We're completely ignored so one of our party goes to the back of the bar to the shower curtain rod to get our coats himself. The woman behind the bar goes bananas and starts screaming at him to get away from the coats. So the hostess finally gets up, gets our coats, and facetiously says something like "Thank you SO much." This is after spending over $400 on dinner. Then, as we're walking out, the woman behind the bar shouts at us "Don't forget to tip your hostess!! HAPPY F@!*ing NEW YEAR!!"We phoned to complain to the manager and his response was "Well what do you want me to do about it? You should have tipped her." Seriously.Appallingly rude service, which is a shame because we all enjoyed our steaks. Do not waste your time or money on this dump, there are hundreds of better steakhouses in NYC.

Sarah O.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 2 January, 2015
This comment was posted anonymously

Disappointed for the price. The butter was frozen and wrapped individually and impossible to spread even on a medium hot baked potato. The steak was just ok. Certainly not worth the price. And the hostesses were rude. They told us we had to eat in under and hour because there was another reservation for our table (which we also reserved). The restrooms were sloppy and very cold. The table was also very cold.

joe  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 8 December, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

is this her, I think shes working at ricks

Nigel  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 19 November, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

I am looking for blonde gabby who used to work a here about two years ago. Anyone know where she works now?

Ashley M.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 16 September, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

This is a classic NYC steak house. Theatre district and very cool. Can feel tight on space and can get loud but it's all NYC. Staff is awesome and steaks are perfect. Small bar upstairs for before or after dinner. Pictures on walls tell the history of this place. Very old school vibe!

Dance Man  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 16 September, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Where is Camilla, I haven't seen her lately. I miss that fine ass of hers

Mary G.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 30 August, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Almost stumbled past this place, ever so glad we stopped in! Very old New York feel, amazing food, over the top drinks and terrific service. We even got a private magic show from one of the owners. It was an amazing time and just a block away from our hotel (Marriott Marquis), which I wouldn't recommend staying at....

Neal F.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 7 August, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

night shift, Brandy, wow tall and exotic, great legs, firm ass. Nice sensual dance also.

Bob Not Quite Italian  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 5 August, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

When does Camilla work? I have to stop by again.

Will  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 19 July, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

What are the rules for touching here? Looking at Camillas ass and not being able to squeeze it would b hell

Dance Fan  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 19 July, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Camilla very very hot. Her dances are excellento!

joe d  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 18 June, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

place is looking better that usual nice girls w hot asses but could not find Gina where is she ??? she still works there??

Harrison69  on  Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 14 May, 2014
Joined 5 years ago
128 comments posted

Been here twice, had the filet once, and the strip. Both were cooked med rare, as ordered, which seems to be a difficult concept to grasp for some places. Rest of the meal was very good quality. Good sized portions, so I'm not offended by the NY sized check. Service was top notch. Booth space is good, but some of the table seating is tight. The price and tight seating costs them a star in my book, but this place is still one of my new fav's.

To Higgs  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 12 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

She is still a daytime girl, and she's there most days.

Higgs  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 11 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Thanks. Was there two years ago. Still can't forget that sweet ass She only work days?. Hope 2 b there soon

To Higgs  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 11 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

You gotta see it to believe it!

Higgs  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 10 April, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Does Camilla still have an ass designed by the gods?

PJ  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 22 March, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

got some dances from camilla were very very hot.

Edward A.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 20 March, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

What a great surprise this was, I wanted to take my wife out for a good steak dinner but since we're not from New York we had no idea where to go, we were walking around Times Square and just as we were about to give in to just any place, i see Frankie & Johnnie's steakhouse out the side of my eye, we walked in and absolutely loved our steaks, would definitely go back.

john fefz  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 15 February, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Who is that super hot blonde girl in the ad? does she work there? what is her name?

Tom L.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 7 February, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Stopped in for a quick lunch bite at the bar and had a some very good food! They have a "bar / happy hour" menu that includes a good selection for stuff for $9. Cheeseburger sliders were on the small side but some of the best sliders I have ever had. Wished I had ordered their full burger as soon as i tasted one. Crabcake bites were very good too. Little burst of horseradish in the cake itself which worked for me but I don't mind horseradish. Filet skewers melted in mouth!Nice strong drinks and good service completed our happy lunch. Cant wait to try them for dinner.

C  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 3 February, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

Was there 2/1/14 had fun. Ladies were nice not pushy like other places. Had a few dances all were good. Will have to make this a weekly thing. Got there too late I guess, two hours not enough, walked in with $400 in pocket left with $260. Claire will you dance for me again?

Aussie Dave  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 13 January, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

OMG, The spectacular Kelly, a fantastic time over 2 nights, sitting back home, wondering how I could have got you in my suitcase.

Priscilla Y.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 7 January, 2014
This comment was posted anonymously

When you walk into the restaurant, you get this snooty vibe, especially from the hostess. The servers are all older in age and the restaurant patrons are also of that age, mostly getting dinner before going to a Broadway show. Luckily, our waitress was super friendly! Forgot her name, but she's a cute redheaded woman.When I got the menu and saw the prices, ... However, the food was delicious, making the price well worth it! I ordered the broiled salmon. It was nicely cooked and pretty big portion. Other restaurants would serve half the portion for the same price.My brother ordered the ribeye. It was amazing! It was huge, soft, and cooked just right! A little fatty though.*The food does not come with sides. They have potato-based side dishes for about $9 each. It is a big portion and enough to share with the entire table.

NIGHT STALKER  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 26 December, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I drink your blood. I eat your skin.

Loretta B.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 5 December, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Don't be put off by the "old school" reviews about this place. The food is fantastic! My family loved the melt-in-your-mouth steaks that were cooked to perfection. I had a delicious hunk of grilled salmon and the best garlic mashed potatoes I have ever tasted. Great location for pre-theater dining. Reservations are highly recommended because this culinary jewel fills up fast.

hot girls??  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 21 November, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

hottest girl here???

Big joe  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 2 November, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I gotta big dick for gabbys fat ass!!

Mick  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 1 November, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

What happened to blonde gabby? Where did she go?

Armon  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 16 September, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Any petite really cute puerto rican hotties work here?

Bill  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 15 September, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Coming to the Big Apple, who's the hottest daytime girl?

R  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 6 September, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I Love You Angelica ;)

Gerry  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 August, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I had such a great time yesterday that it was hard for me to leave. Kisses to all the dancers especially Grace, Gabriela and Erica.

Tough C.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 19 August, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

In the heart of the Theatre District you can find this spot that seems to be trapped in time. The walls are decorated by big Broadway shows posters. The wait staff is very efficient and they have an "old school" charm to them. Good spot to have a nice dinner before or after one of your Broadway shows. It is a little pricey but the food is decent. Try the filet!

Horny  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 31 July, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Daytime girl with the bubble butt, anyone take her to the champagne.

joe big  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 27 July, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

wow had a great time here the other night dropped in with my wife for a few drinks and we had a blast. Def thumbs up..! .and hey this new web site looks and works awesome def very cool as well!

Brian  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 2 July, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

The host there is very beutifull.I would love to meet her

Brian  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 2 July, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I think Eva is the most beutiful woman there

PJ  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 26 May, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Camilla baby, you make me a mad thing.

Joe  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 May, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

mad thing

sl  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 17 May, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

gabi's amazing...so hot and great with dances

Jana H.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 18 April, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

*3.5 stars but I rounded it up based on service & overall experience-Price: $25-$50 (without beverages)-Location: Theater District - West 45th St. & 8th Ave-Ambiance: An intimate old school restaurant that brings one back in time-Staff/ Waiters: Friendly, Attentive, Charming, Knowledgeable & Efficient-Menu: Standard Steak House fare; steak, vegetables, potatoes, seafood etc.-Nit Picky: Clean - Tables are close together - Not ADA friendly (Americans with Disabilities Act), due to small space and having to go up and down stairs to get to restaurant and bathroom(s)-Good For: Dinner before/ after a show or date nightFood:-Free bread served when you sit down. The bread actually tastes decent and isn't dry, plus they give you as much as you want-Frankie & Johnnies Steak Sauce is delicious! It's a mixture between A-1, smokey BBQ Sauce and ketchup! I was pouring this sauce on just about everything! I almost purchased a bottle but I didn't want to carry it into the theater-Big Portions: Come hungry-The Potato Pancakes are craveable! Frankie & Johnnie's puts a twist on the standard greasy flat pancakes by making them fluffy, round and light. They reminded me of the doughnut version of potato pancakes. -The low point of the night was the garlic mashed potatoes. The potatoes were very thin, soupy and on the verge of tasting like they came from a pre-made box mixture that one can find at your local grocery store. -The Grilled Breast of Chicken was forgettable. Not good, not bad. The meat was thin and a tad dry. -The bacon tasted funny. I can't pin-point what the "funny" taste is, however it may have been seasoned or smoked in a weird / non-traditional way. -The ground Angus beef was juicy, cooked well and beyond filling! Overall it tasted fine but it's not something that I would order again.Frankie & Johnnie's is worth dining at based on price, service, location and the atmosphere. Although I'm not rushing to come back here anytime soon, I wouldn't be opposed to dining here in the future.

Roger  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 14 April, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

nice

Tommyboy  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 18 March, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Does Bianca still work there?

Tommyboy  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 18 March, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

Does Bianca still work there?

beans  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 12 February, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

goodluck

Linda M.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 23 January, 2013
This comment was posted anonymously

I have been going to Frankie & Johnnies for several years now. I have never had a bad meal. I love the fact that it was a speakeasy in years back and thoroughly enjoy the atmosphere. My salads, steak, seafood and desserts have also been top notch. I particularly enjoy the lamb chop or the veal chop - I actually think these are my favorites. The desserts are decadent and never had any problems. Yes its tight in there, but that's okay with me, its fun to meet people - and we've met people from all over. We've even been there and met a few stars having dinner. We've seen Tony Roberts there a few times having dinner with his daughter. So if he eats there it has to be good. I go back every chance I can for a special dinner or celebration.

Annunaki  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 27 December, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

To Mark / Dec 13 2012 08:53AM:Her name is Melissa

Juan  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 16 December, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

It's Jennifer, the one with the huge breasts!

Mark  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 13 December, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

A few months ago I was up in NY, and met such a nice girl at Private Eyes. She was a beautiful, chinese, and funny. She's the one that sells the bottles. Please can someone tell me her name. I would love to send her a little something. Thanks!

Rubens  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 26 November, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

anyone has been to a flashdancers/ny dolls/private eyez christmas parties? are they worth it? thanks.

Gerry  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 November, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

I had a great time there yesterday. Vicky, Daniela and Rose were alot of fun.

Texas  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 12 November, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

Happy Birthday Jennifer! I'll see you when I get back!

Ray  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 11 November, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

I was at PI with my friends on Saturday night 11/10. It was amazing. Spent most of my time with Maya. She is simple gorgeous. Loved the dance!

Name?  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 10 November, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

Was here early Friday 11/9.. Big surprise after 8pm shift change. Night dancers were not butt ugly but daytime dancers were better looking to me and by then I already had a few drinks. Daytime hostess is way hot. Next time I will have to bring more than lapdance and drink money.

Jersey Guy  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 3 November, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

Is club operating post "SANDY"Is the Lebonese girl still working there? She was dressed all in red on a a Wed about a month ago? Her hair was red too. And she had a beautiful figure. Want to hang out with her again. I think she came from FDancers

Nick  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 25 October, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

What happened to Daniella? I'd like to see her again!

Sammy  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 6 October, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

You have the hostess Jenifer, she's Chinese!!! Huge breasts!!! She's very friendly!!! Very Friendly!!!

Bill  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 27 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

How much is a champagne room?

rick  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 26 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

there are asians there not many but there are at each shift

james  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

I had a great time with my brother- very nice ladies here indeed....stunning.

#31 Ichiro's Best Fan  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 24 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

Any pretty Chinese or Japanese girls there? Much appreciated!

david  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 21 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

nicole is the hottest girl there go check her out

Mark M.  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 12 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

This was my 3rd visit this year and the food and service was excellent as always. I have always sat at the tiny bar area where Ana Maria is always pleasant and helpful. Was surprised when the waiter Mario actually remembered my name. I have searched the country for great tasting steaks and can say Frankie & Johnnie's is in my top 5!

rick  on Private Eyes Gentlemen's Club NYC

posted on 12 August, 2012
This comment was posted anonymously

lets not forget about Tiffany, the awesome one

Previous Page123456Next Page

Share This Page